Constitutional FAQ Answer #27
This is part three of a three-part question pertaining to the "Nanny Trial" in Fall, 1997.
Q27. "And also, what rights do Deborah and Sunil Eappen have as relatives of the victim? Could they sue Judge Zobel on constitutional grounds?"
A. None. Victims have no constitutional rights, as victims. It is, perhaps, sad to say, but there it is. This was, however, a state trial, and they may have certain rights as victims in Massachusetts. I haven't ever heard, though, of a judge ever being sued by anyone involved in a criminal case because of a particular decision in that case. Unless there are some specific grounds in a specific
state, I don't even know what kind of grounds one would have to sue a judge because of a decision or ruling in a court case.